Skip Navigation Links
Skip Navigation Links
January 2021Expand January 2021
November 2020Expand November 2020
July/August 2020Expand July/August 2020
May/June 2020Expand May/June 2020
March/April 2020Expand March/April 2020
January/February 2020Expand January/February 2020
September/October 2019Expand September/October 2019
July/August 2019Expand July/August 2019
May/June 2019Expand May/June 2019
March/April 2019Expand March/April 2019
January/February 2019Expand January/February 2019
November/December 2018Expand November/December 2018
September/October 2018Expand September/October 2018
July/August 2018Expand July/August 2018
May/June 2018Expand May/June 2018
March/April 2018Expand March/April 2018
January/February 2018Expand January/February 2018
November/December 2017Expand November/December 2017
September/October 2017Expand September/October 2017
July/August 2017Expand July/August 2017
May/June 2017Expand May/June 2017
March/April 2017Expand March/April 2017
January/February 2017Expand January/February 2017
November/December 2016Expand November/December 2016
September/October 2016Expand September/October 2016
July/August 2016Expand July/August 2016
May/June 2016Expand May/June 2016
March/April 2016Expand March/April 2016
January/February 2016Expand January/February 2016
November/December 2015Expand November/December 2015
September/October 2015Expand September/October 2015
July/August 2015Expand July/August 2015
May/June 2015Expand May/June 2015
March/April 2015Expand March/April 2015
January/February 2015Expand January/February 2015
ArchiveExpand Archive
Special Edition - EPRExpand Special Edition - EPR
Special Edition: Title V Technical Assistance MeetingExpand Special Edition: Title V Technical Assistance Meeting
Title V Technical Assistance Meeting

 A View from Washington

Family Separations as an MCH Issue

By Amy Haddad
Director of Policy and Government Affairs
Association of Maternal & Child Health Programs

In early June, many of us were shocked to learn that the Trump administration's new "zero tolerance" immigration policy resulted in the separation of children from their families. As an organization devoted to promoting maternal and child health, AMCHP weighed if and how to take a position on what would normally be an immigration policy issue – and therefore could be considered outside our wheelhouse.

However, AMCHP soon joined the chorus of public health and health provider organizations in urging the administration to reverse the policy and to immediately take steps to reunite families who had been separated. Our statement  highlighted the well-documented "impact of adverse childhood experiences on a variety of physical and emotional health problems that last well into adulthood," and noted that "separation from their parents is undeniably a traumatic event for these children."

Bipartisan opposition to the policy of separating families and the conditions under which immigrants and asylum-seekers are being held stood out in a Congress where bipartisan agreement on anything is rare these days. In an effort to take a stand against the situation, members of Congress have visited detention centers, introduced bills, and passed amendments in committee. In July, the House Appropriations Committee passed a slew of amendments to the Labor, Health, and Human Services and Education appropriations bill as well as the Homeland Security appropriations bill, including amendments that: express the view of Congress that families shouldn't be separated; fund mental health services for children who have been separated from their parents; prevent the forced medication of separated children without a medical assessment, including a trauma assessment; fund health services, alternatives to detention, and family case management services; and prohibit Immigration and Customs Enforcement from using restraints on a pregnant detainee in most circumstances.

However, none of these amendments will go into effect until the underlying bills to which they were attached become law – possibly months from now, if at all. With President Trump recently again stating that he would be willing to shut down the government over a lack of funding for a proposed border wall, it's probable that issues related to immigration – and specifically the issues related to separating families – would dominate a lot of the discourse around preventing a government shutdown as we near the Sept. 30 deadline for passing funding bills for fiscal year 2019. While I am optimistic that the government will not shut down, we need to be prepared for all possible scenarios.

As the countdown until fiscal year 2019 begins and current government funding expires, part of that preparation is continuing to weigh the role AMCHP will play in any debate or actions on issues related to immigration and family separations. AMCHP's 2018 Policy Agenda is clear that we will promote policies to address the prevention and mitigation of adverse childhood experiences and toxic stress, and it is primarily through this lens that we will remain engaged where possible.